avocets
Avocets
rss 2.0 subscribe to this page
search


view all
•  projects
•  owners
•  tags

Margaret Marini states the differences between men and women are natural for biological reasons but there are some stereotypical differences based on social roles and status.  She believes that the role of breadwinner has always been the male's responsibility and therefore female breadwinner or working women are considered masculine, unfit or inappropriate.  While these stereotypes are changing, it is still prevalent in the society.

Marini, Margaret M. “Sex and Gender: What Do We Know?” Sociological Forum 5.1 (1990): 95-120.

Boris, Eileen.  “Gender After Africa!”  Africa After Gender.  Ed. Catherine M. Cole, Takyiwaa Manuh, and Stephan F. Miescher.  Bloomington, IN : Indiana University Press, 2007.  191-204.

Eileen Boris opens her essay by turning a common question asked by Western gender academics on its head. Instead of asking “What impact has gender as a category of analysis had on the study of Africa,” which in itself assumes Western thinkers have already arrived at a correct framework for studying gender, the author argues that a much more appropriate question is “What can Africa do for gender?” She explains how Western gender theorists have, until recently, incorrectly proposed their own historical gender tradition to be universal. Instead, historical African social and gender structures need to be used to enlarge the framework for academic gender theory. Additionally, she explores the similarities and differences between gender and other social attributes such as age, lineage, kinship and wealth for determining social status. Finally, she shows how African gender is a source of power in post-colonial political struggles.

In many ways, this article reveals the Western bias in my original thesis for this research project (I actually still retained the same thesis, as it is a case in point for Eileen Boris’s and many other African gender scholars). My thesis assumes that gender and feminism thought in Africa need a Western savior-that African women have to find a balance between their “primitive” gender tradition and the “correct” or “modern” Western ideas of gender and liberation. It also makes me wonder what opinions about gender roles director Ousmane Sembène might have had in mind when he released Xala. Most of the Western analysis of the film describe women in the film as “masculine,” and the men as “feminine,” but Boris’s article suggests such reviews assume Western gender stereotypes are universal. Did Sembène have this in mind as well?

belongs to Xala project
tagged africa feminism gender_studies by joshuamv ...on 10-APR-08
Amadiume, Ifi. African Gender Studies: a Reader. Ed. Oyeronke Oyewumi. New York, NY: Palgrave, 2005. 83-97.
 
In chapter 5 of this anthology, author Ifi Amadiume shows that Western scholarly theories on African communities are dramatically Eurocentric, forcing a dichotomized choice between patriarchal and matriarchal patterns for the foundation for viewing social structure. This approach is heavily biased, and thus has made study of African kinship idealogies problematic for Western scholars. Additionally, it shows the forcing of European patriarchy patterns onto African communities has made it difficult for post-colonial Africa to return and even differentiate between tradition and modernity. The article goes on to discuss a multitude of examples of matriarchical rule in pre-colonial African communities, including specific matriarchic “family units” – a sharp contrast to Western family units. These examples, in fact, shake many western psychological paradigms, and have stretched Western thought to question the patriarchal legacy which is often associated with ideas of state, order, power and modernity.
 
This article is relevant to the film Xala in the way it challenges the cultural normality of male-female power balances in the film. It suggests that the patriarchy portrayed in the film, both in family and state structures, was just another instance of European destruction of pre-colonial African culture. One can then argue that the incompetence of the (male) ruling elite in the film reflects post-colonial Africa’s “fish out of water” condition as it still emulates European traditions.
belongs to Xala project
tagged gender_studies post_colonialism by joshuamv ...on 10-APR-08